Beyond The Wall
I have know watched "Beyond The Wall" twice and listened to a few instant reaction podcasts. This episode has seemed to left some people complaining about the believability factor. This is a fantasy show, some of the nitpicking is rather ridiculous, but that doesn't mean I don't have my own complaints about the episode itself. I'm not bothered by the fast traveling, but the writing of the Stark girls is leaving me pissed. As far as the complaints go about fast traveling ...they were stuck beyond the wall for nearly two full days. If you pay attention the sun is down when Gendry makes it back to the Wall and it's a new day when the ice battle happens. When Dany arrives it seems to be getting near dark again, which meant the Ravens had all night to travel to Dragonstone. I'll assume they arrived in the morning and that dragons travel faster. Unfortunately the season is short, so short cuts are necessary and I'm not going to complain as long as stuff makes sense.
The stuff in Winterfell is making less sense to me and I almost wish that we didn't get any Winterfell scenes at all verses a convoluted storyline. On the first watch I hated every bit of it. Even though Sansa and Arya were never close to begin with, it's still hard to watch the last remaining Starks argue. I remember in season one when Ned told them that they are sisters and they have to stick together....
The first scene with Arya and Sansa started out great, Arya is reminiscing with Sansa about their father, which always gets me emotional when they bring up Ned. As Arya is telling Sansa about the time he watched her training with a bow, the sweet moment turned super dark when Arya accuses Sansa of helping the Lannister's kill their father and starts reading the scroll that Sansa wrote under duress. I felt Arya was way over the line in her accusations towards Sansa. Sansa was totally in the right to defend herself. She was a stupid little girl. I understand Arya's anger, because I remember hating Sansa a lot in season one for her idiotic naïveté that led to Ned's arrest, but I was cheering for Sansa standing her ground and even taking credit for winning back Winterfell. Sansa's not wrong. She's been through a lot, she's grown up and she's not the same girl anymore.
The next Winterfell scene leads into Sansa talking to Littlefinger about Arya. It was actually a great scene too. Sansa is worrying about what the northern houses would do if they find out about the letter and she's confessing her fears to Littlefinger about Arya being a danger. I think at this point Sansa's concerns are valid, but opening up to Littlefinger is completely and utterly stupid on her part. Of course he cleverly manipulates the situation and brings up Brienne's sworn oath to protect them both. This brings us to another scene that actually pissed me off. Sansa receives a Raven that summons her to Kings Landing and she decides to force Brienne to go and represent her. Brienne is protesting and doesn't want to leave Sansa unprotected, but Sansa flat out acts like a bitch towards her and forces her to go. I wanted to smack her for the way she acted towards Brienne, but I also felt like it was purposely done to get her out of the way for some other reason that's not quite clear.
The last Winterfell scene is the one that bothered me most of all. Sansa is searching Arya's room for the scroll when she discovers the severed faces, Arya sneaks up behind her and starts acting like a freaking psychopath! I mean she is straight up Dark Arya as she tells Sansa about her faceless man training and that she can become anyone she wants to be, even her and all she would need is her face. I was really tense during this scene! Arya was holding the catspaw's blade and for a second I thought she was going to flat out kill Sansa, so when she handed her the blade I was relieved. I really hated this on first watch because I felt it was just over the top and ridiculously bad writing as well as pointless screen time to create drama between the sisters. On second viewing I still didn't like it much, but I've come around into thinking that there may be something more going on. I'm hoping this is some set up to kill Littlefinger, but even if it is, I think the way they're getting there is extremely annoying. I'd rather just have a scene of Bran telling Sansa and Arya he's behind it all than having to watch forced drama between them. All of this at Winterfell just really affected the episode as a whole for me.
Although I found little joy in Winterfell, I loved everything else. Dany and Tyrion had great scenes with great conversations, but the majority of the episode took place beyond the Wall with Jon, Tormund, Gendry, The Hound, Beric, Thoros and Jorah. Even though the plan to go beyond the wall was entirely stupid, I loved seeing all these people interact once they got there! Tormund and The Hound were hilarious. One of my favorite parts of the episode is when Tormund is declaring his love to Brienne to the Hound. Sandor's reaction to Tormund's crush was hilarious. We got comedy, but we also got an extremely touching scene between Jon and Jorah. Jon reveals to Jorah that has Longclaw, given to him by Jorah's father. Jon offers it back to Jorah and Jorah tells him to keep it because he doesn't deserve it for the shame he brought to his family. This is probably one of my favorite moments in the episode. It was a touching moment between two characters that hardly know each other, but the sincerity of the moment felt real due to their mutual respect for Jorah's father.
There was several fun conversations and interactions between all characters to some degree, but then the first danger strikes when they get attacked by a reanimated dead polar bear! When that bear jumped out and attacked one of the nameless characters it gave me a jump scare. The bear kills one of the nameless characters and they set it on fire, the burning bear attacks Thoros and injuries him badly but he survives the initial attack. After they survive the polar bear attack they continue their journey and find a group of wights with a White Walker. They set up a trap to capture one of the wights. It works at first until the wight sends out a scream alerting the rest of the dead to danger. That's the only way I can describe what happened, because suddenly the entire group is over run by the dead. Jon makes Gendry run back to the Wall to get a raven to Dragonstone. The rest of the group start running and make their way to a frozen lake with an island in the middle. As thousands of the dead begin to cross the ice, it breaks and they sink to the bottom as our group watch from safety.
This is where the episode gets a little bizarre and you have to suspend disbelief to a certain extent, because the Night King is there and chooses to wait them out. I feel like he has the ice magic to refreeze the lake, but he just stands and watches them almost like it's part of plan. We see it's nightfall when Gendry makes it back to the Wall and tells Davos to get a raven to Dragonstone. The group remains stranded over night and Thoros succumbs to his wounds. I had been spoiled on his death thanks to the internet, but losing the the red priest was still a little sad. This also means that Beric has no one to revive him the next time he dies, which I felt was likely to happen before the episode was over because upon realizing the lake is re frozen (thanks to the Hound), the wights start attacking our group. This was a super intense scene and I thought for sure Tormund would die at one point as the wights were trying to pull him beneath the water, but the Hound saves him. The group is still over powered and over run by the dead and it looks like all hope is lost. I know this would have been an incredibly emotional moment, but thanks to the leaks, I was spoiled on what would happen, so I knew Dany would show up and save them. However that scene was absolutely stunning and breathtaking as all the dragons fly in and start spitting fire at the end. The music that plays for these moments with the dragons also makes the scenes even more impactful. As Dany is getting the group on top of Drogon, Viserion and Rhaegal are still catching the dead on fire ....then it cuts to the Night King as an Other hands him this giant ice spear. My heart stopped at this moment, because I knew what was about to happen. The Night King throws the spear and hits Viserion, the dragon starts bleeding Fire and falls to his death and sinks beneath the lake as Dany watches. This scene was one of the most gut punching moments in the entire series! I know they're cgi dragons, but they're real in the context of the show and we have watched them grow up for season years and seeing one die left me in tears. It was such a tragic moment. Now we know that the dragons can easily be killed by the Night King and this changes everything.
Jon is still trying to fight off the dead and for some dumb reason tells Dany to leave without him to get everyone to safety. Why he stayed behind didn't make any sense, but the Night King is throwing another ice spear and Drogon flies and dodges it thankfully! Jon gets dragged beneath the water by the dead ...but then he comes up again. Not sure what this is supposed to mean?? But he's still stranded and out numbered by the army, until Uncle Benjen shows up and rescues him, sacrificing himself in the process. I was let down by this particular part. I would have loved to have had more scenes between Jon and his uncle, and this is a moment that I think is ruined by the faster paces storytelling of this season. But at least Jon is alive and he makes it back to Eastwatch to the relief of Dany.
I loved the next scene! They're taking Jon's frozen armour off and as Dany looks on, she finally sees all his wounds he suffered at the hands of the Night Watch, including the one in his chest. In that moment she's understands that there is something truly special about Jon Snow. Dany is sitting by his side when he wakes up and Jon apologizes to her for going beyond the wall and costing her the life of one of her dragons. Dany has tears in her eyes as she tells him she's not not sorry, because now she's knows and she makes a promise to help him defeat the Night King. Then something monumental happens! Jon calls Daenerys his Queen! This is something I did NOT want to happen in earlier episodes because Dany was trying to make him bend the knee and as I've said in an earlier blog, I always loved her arc because people chose to follow her. Jon is choosing to follow her now because he believes in her and I think it was a touching moment.
The episode ends on a game changing moment that was completely spoiled for me. We go back beyond the wall and see the dead using these giant chains to pull a dead Viserion out of the water. Then the Night King walks over and touches the dragon and Viserion opens blue eyes ...the Night King now has his own weapon of mass destruction to use against Daenerys. I can't even imagine what this is going to mean for all the living.
Beyond the Wall that had some incredible moments and for the most part I loved it. The stuff in Winterfell is the only stuff I out right hated, but another thing did nag me about this episode. I still can't figure out why the White Walkers didn't use ice magic to freeze the lake. I swear it's like they purposely waited for Daenerys to arrive, like they knew she would be coming. Having the chains there and ready also makes me feel like he knew and this was all a plan to trap them so he could get his own dead dragon to control. I can't help but to wonder if the Night King has green seeing powers like Bran. Hopefully with next week's season finale we get some actual answers from Bran!
7/10